Fundraising is probably the part of my job that I like the least - motivating kids to do something that has nothing to do with music, convincing parents to participate, receipting money, handing out orders, etc... All of these things take a significant amount of time away from the classroom. I remember my first year teaching - the parent group had committed to several fundraisers before I was hired. Being a new teacher, and not wanting to anger parents, I decided to follow through with the their plans. What a mistake!
The first fundraiser that year did okay. We made about $4000 profit. So, I bought a tuba. At our next parent meeting I remember a parent asking me, "So, we raised all of that money for an instrument only one kid can use." Now, from a band director's point of view, this is ridiculous, right? A good tuba makes the band sound better, and helps everyone. However, this seems like a legitimate concern from a middle school band parent who knows nothing about band. I continued to run all of these fundraisers, each one did worse and worse, and the last one didn't even break $1000. Parents were tired of being asked to buy junk and food - wrapping paper, overpriced toys and candles, frozen pizza kits, etc... During all of this, they were also being asked to raise money for other groups - beta club, PTA, etc...
So, after my second year, I decided that I had enough fundraising. I couldn't take it anymore. I went to college to teach, not be a fundraiser. I decided that any fundraiser I did from now on should meet the following criteria:
1. It should take little or no classroom time. No more putting charts up in my room, handing out prizes, asking kids what they have sold. No more, it has to be easier and shouldn't interfere with instruction.
2. It should involve me as little as possible. The band program does not serve the director, it serves the kids and families. I believe very strongly that parents should be actively involved. If I can't find volunteers to help run fundraising activities, then we won't do them. This has never been a problem for me - if parents understand why you need the funds, and are given a quality product, they are usually glad to help. As a parent, I will help with anything that makes my kids happy.
3. It should raise a significant amount of money. This is a matter of opinion. How much is a significant amount? Is the amount of money worth the time involved. For example, I will not do a car wash. Besides the fact that my principal does not like them, you waste an entire day, a dozen or more kids, to make $400. There is also safety and liability concerns here, not worth it. I do a Pancake Breakfast Concert each year, however, that also takes a Saturday. The difference is that the kids are performing their fall concert, and we make several thousand dollars. I plan to blog about that later.
4. It should be planned well in advance. This seems like common sense, but I can't tell you the number of times I have seen people, including myself, plan one at the last second to get some money. This will usually flop.
5. Simpler is better. Have you ever thought about asking for money? I have a "Friends of Music" program that raises several thousand dollars each year. You collect the money, and you are done. Plus, you are not sending 60% of the money to some fundraising company. Now - don't just go and say "please send cash!" There is a right way and wrong way to do this. I will blog about this later on too.
6. Less is more. A couple of well-planned and well-executed fundraisers are much better than half of a dozen other ones.
I'll be posting good fundraising ideas over the next couple of weeks. Have one to share? If so, leave it in the comments.
For many reasons I haven't been posting here for a while, I plan to write more regularly now. If you have suggestions for topics, please let me know!